I'd like a try at the Schmidt and maybe the Clemens/Carlton. Let me see what I can find.
For the Schmidt Auto:
$10+ Cards
1991 Topps Desert Shield #318 Rick Aguilera $10.00
2005 Bowman Chrome Draft Gold Refractor Mike Durant #BDP60 $30.00
2009 SP Authentic Gold #147 Mat Latos $12.00
2010 Bowman Sterling Refractors #50 Brett Wallace $10.00
2010 Upper Deck Gold #187 Franklin Morales $12.00
2010 Upper Deck Gold #289 Corey Hart $12.00
2011 Topps Black #483 Justin Smoak $60.00
2011 Topps Heritage Black #C4 Miguel Cabrera - $12.00
2011 Topps Heritage Black #C5 Starlin Castro $12.00
2011 Topps Heritage Black #C43 Don Mattingly $20.00
2011 Topps Heritage Black #C74 Joe Mauer $12.00
2012 Bowman Platinum Ruby #8 Ichiro Suzuki $10.00
2012 Topps Chrome Sepia Refractors #137 B.J. Upton $10.00
Total: $222.00/5 = $44.40
$5-$8 Cards
1996 Topps Mantle Finest #6 Mickey Mantle 1956 Topps $8.00
1996 Topps Mantle Finest #7 Mickey Mantle 1957 Topps $8.00
1997 Topps Mantle #29 Mickey Mantle/1960 Topps AS $8.00
1997 Topps Mantle #32 Mickey Mantle/1961 Topps AS $8.00
1998 Pinnacle Plus Piece of the Game #9 Nomar Garciaparra $8.00
1998 Upper Deck Tape Measure Titans Gold #26 Sammy Sosa $8.00
1999 Finest Complements Dual Refractors #C4 Juan Gonzalez/Sammy Sosa $8.00
2000 Metal Hit Machines #H2 Mark McGwire $5.00
2003 Bowman Draft #138 Ryan Howard RC $6.00
2003 Leaf Certified Materials Mirror Red #167 Rafael Soriano $5.00
2005 Donruss All-Stars AL Gold #2 Alfonso Soriano $6.00
2005 Origins Red #51 Alfonso Soriano $8.00
2007 Upper Deck Premier #219 Tim Gradoville RC $5.00
2008 Topps Moments and Milestones Black #155 Billy Buckner $6.00
2008 Topps Moments and Milestones Black #155 Billy Buckner $6.00
2008 UD Masterpieces #112 Mike Schmidt SP $5.00
2009 SP Authentic #147 Mat Latos RC $8.00
2009 TRISTAR Prospects Plus #53 William Myers $8.00
2010 Bowman Sterling Prospects #AC Aroldis Chapman $5.00
2010 Bowman Sterling Prospects Refractors #RE Robbie Erlin $8.00
2010 Topps 206 Mini Cycle #32 Brad Hawpe $5.00
2010 Topps Chrome X-Fractors #126 Ryan Howard $5.00
2011 Bowman Platinum Emerald #100 Ichiro Suzuki $6.00
2011 Bowman Platinum Ruby #30 Felix Hernandez $6.00
2011 Topps Chrome X-Fractors #188 Alexi Ogando $5.00
2011 Topps Heritage Black #C59 Delmon Young $8.00
2011 Topps Heritage Black #C75 Tommy Hunter $5.00
2011 Topps Pro Debut Double-A All Stars #DA23 Brett Lawrie $5.00
2011 Topps Pro Debut Gold #133 Daniel Fields $5.00
2012 Bowman Chrome Draft #4 Yoenis Cespedes RC $5.00
2012 Bowman Platinum Emerald #19 Dustin Pedroia $5.00
2012 Topps Chrome Black Refractors #77 Tim Hudson $8.00
2012 Topps Chrome Black Refractors #132 Adrian Beltre $5.00
2012 Topps Chrome Black Refractors #142 Yovani Gallardo $5.00
2012 Topps Chrome Dynamic Die Cuts #BP Buster Posey $6.00
2012 Topps Chrome Dynamic Die Cuts #JV Justin Verlander $5.00
2012 Topps Chrome Sepia Refractors #134 Melky Cabrera $6.00
2012 Topps Heritage Minors Black #20 Nolan Arenado $8.00
Total: $240/6 = $40
GU/Autos
2006 Upper Deck Future Stars #128 Ben Hendrickson AU (RC) $8.00
2011 Bowman Platinum Prospect Autograph Refractors #JP Jimmy Paredes $8.00
2011 Topps Chrome Rookie Autographs #184 Eric Sogard $8.00
2001 Fleer Red Sox 100th #NNO Field the Game/7150 $30.00
2012 Topps Allen and Ginter Relics #BA Bobby Abreu $8.00
2012 Topps Allen and Ginter Relics #CBI Chad Billingsley $8.00
2012 Topps Heritage Clubhouse Collection Relics #NM Nyjer Morgan $8.00
Total: $78/4.5 = $17.33
Total = $101.73 for $100 Schmidt Auto