I need some input from the forum. I bought a box of 2012 Tribute. This was the first high end box I ever purchased. I was very excited to find a Willie Mays auto redemption card inside. Here's the problem. It had a scratch off portion to reveal the code for redemption. When I went to scratch it off it wouldn't come off. I scratched a little harder and it just smeared and ripped the code. Now there is no way to read it. There are 4 or 5 legible letters/numbers. Here's what scares me : the back of the card says "cards will be judged void if illegible, altered, mutilated, forged, tampered with in any way.". I really believe this card to be defective. Has anybody here ever had anything like this happen to them? Any input would be greatly appreciated.